I wished Joe had been rather more genteelly brought up, and then I should have been so too.
— Great Expectations, Charles Dickens
We begin Charles Dickens’s Great Expectations despite Richard’s adolescent fears. Turns out it’s good and maybe even easy to read. Even for Cam.
Foot maxxing: Before class anxiety, we quickly ponder shoe size anxiety and the unpredictable (positive?) effects from jogging.
Dickens is good, actually: We are pleasantly surprised by how readable, playful, and funny (at least in a micro sense) Dickens is. We say this despite university students reliably failing to comprehend Bleak House.
The original status anxiety novel: Pip’s status and class anxieties feel surprisingly contemporary for Rich, who we learn was the 20th century Pip with only half as many hang ups.
shoe size discourse
Benny: Boys, I wanna see you guys in a month. I’m stoked. Coming soon.
Rich: Oh, hell yeah. I can’t wait.
Benny: Not too far at all. We’ll be on our next monstrous book by then, surely, or our third Dickens. We’ll see what happens.
Rich: Let’s just go Dickens. Let’s read his entire catalog.
Cam: I could finally finish a corpus.
Benny: I’m not opposed.
Cam: The pharmacist yesterday noticed I had the book, and he said, “Oh, you’re into Dickens.” So he’s a big fan, and then it turned out he’d only read A Christmas Carol. But he recommended I read it. He’d been advertising himself as this Dickens fan.
Rich: I mean, that describes me up until two weeks ago. Which is, like, the shortest one, for babies. Well, I didn’t read it. I saw the animated adaptation of it.
Benny: I’ve heard it’s very true to the original work, though. A Christmas Carol is my dad’s favorite movie — the old-school one, the 1953 version. He makes us watch it every Christmas. I know it line by line.
Cam: I haven’t even… I should watch it this Christmas.
Benny: Honestly, it’s a good one. It’s pretty epic. It’s got a lot of banging lines.
Rich: Speaking of banging lines, Benny, your voice is quite a bit louder than Cam’s and mine. Could you turn yourself down a bit? Or, Cam, turn yourself up a bit? Or Cam, maybe you don’t touch yours, because I trust you less. Okay. Talking.
Benny: Talking. Talking.
Cam: Testing. How’ve you been? How’ve you been, for real, right now? I actually had a Nathan Fielder moment the other day at the shoe store.
Benny: Nice.
Cam: We were getting new shoes, but we were at an outlet store, so they didn’t have heaps of the sizes. So I went and asked the clerk, and I needed to ask for, like, size five or six or something. And she’s looking in the system, and I’m just standing there quietly, and I sort of lean in, and I’m like, “They’re not for me, by the way.” Because in my head, she thinks I’m wearing size five shoes.
Rich: Is there even a size five for men? I’ve never even heard of it.
Cam: Maybe not. It was size six and a half. I slightly exaggerated it. Also, I suddenly thought, maybe you guys are size six and a half, and I didn’t want… So I went a bit lower in case that was the punchline.
Benny: Thanks, bro. I appreciate the vote of confidence in my shoe size.
Cam: Yeah. Nothing wrong with that.
Rich: You ruined your own joke by trying to be sensitive to your tiny-footed friends.
Benny: That’s hilarious. I do have small feet, but not that small.
Rich: What are we rocking, Benny?
Benny: Yikes.
Cam: Size fives.
Benny: Not size fives, but not double. Not double size fives. I’m at, like, eight and a half. What are you?
Rich: I’m 9.5.
Cam: Size thirteen.
Benny: I didn’t like that, little passive aggressive.
Rich: No, that’s cute, man. That’s cute.
Benny: Take your big foot energy out of here, bro.
Rich: I’ve got marginally bigger feet. I’m like, oh, yeah.
Cam: Half a size bigger.
Rich: My feet grew since I started running, which is weird. I used to be a size nine, and now I’m a nine and a half. They spread out.
Cam: Well, I assume you know you’re meant to wear a bigger size, right?
Rich: Well, yeah, you have to. Otherwise they’re too small.
Cam: Yeah. I always get bleeding toes.
Rich: No, but now my normal shoes from before are too small as well. So something happened. My foot got wider.
Benny: What? Wow. But not longer? It just got wider?
Cam: That makes zero sense.
Rich: That would be cool if they got a bit longer. Wouldn’t mind another half inch.
Benny: Wow. All the runners are messing with the foot–dick size correlation. That’s rough.
Rich: If you repetitively slapped your dick against concrete thousands of times in a row, would that have the same effect?
Benny: Surely. Surely it would help.
Cam: Girth, not length, apparently.
Benny: Just have a massive… “Don’t worry, babe. I did this for you.”
Rich: That’s like Clavicular style, right? He’s, like, bashing his face.
Cam: Yeah. Bashing your jaws.
Benny: There we go. Sacrifice for the game. Chewing that really heavy gum as you’re slapping your dick against the concrete. The kids are alright.
Cam: But yeah, it’s confusing, because run clubs are dating things. Everyone’s got a size and a half too big, confusing the signal, putting the shoes on.
Rich: Big clown shoes. Hey, is it true that shoe size and dick size are correlated?
Benny: Surely it has to be.
Cam: Body size. Most things are in proportion, right?
Rich: But are they?
Cam: Although I played soccer with a guy who swore it wasn’t. He had small feet, but he was convincing.
Benny: He was convincing and desperate.
Rich: How did he convince you?
Cam: Yeah. Massive. Massive and strong.
Rich: He convinced you how big his dick was by talking about it persuasively.
Cam: It’s like you’ve been doing a study, almost.
Rich: Ethnographic research.
Cam: Yeah. So I think Benny’s gotta go soon. It’s been a good fifteen minutes on the important stuff.
Rich: Well, he’s gone. He’s just vanished.
Benny: All the time I had for you. We got to get stuff done.
Cam: Alright. Even though we’re having fun, let’s get into it.
Rich: Yeah. Let’s stop having fun and talk about the book.
Benny: Usually, when we get into it, we’ve totally stopped having fun. We’re pissed.
dickens is kinda good
Cam: Today, we’re doing Charles Dickens’ Great Expectations. We’re doing not quite the first half — up to around page 200, or maybe around chapter 30, which is part one and a little bit of part two, actually. So that’s what we’re covering today. And I thought we’d start with first impressions of the book. In the group chat, there were some pretty positive reactions around Dickens and this book. Rich, I’ll hand to you.
Rich: Well, I feel embarrassed that when you announced the next pick, we were like, “Oh, come on. You said it was gonna be an easy one. We have to read Charles Dickens?”
Cam: Yeah. That was on mic, wasn’t it?
Rich: And then it turns out to be a very easy, fun read. I guess I look like an idiot now, but it’s a good thing to be wrong about. I’m just flying through this one. It’s so fun and funny.
And I wouldn’t have guessed a Victorian morality tale about status anxiety would translate so well to this day and age, but it still feels quite relevant and fresh, even though we have a much more collapsed class structure and status hierarchy. It feels pretty evergreen. So, yeah, I’m enjoying it heaps.
Cam: Yeah. It’s funny. I was finding it hard to describe how it’s funny, but there’s a very kind of Englishness to the humor as well. It reminds me a little bit of, I don’t know, Douglas Adams and Stephen Fry.
Rich: To me, it just feels like he’s having fun as he’s writing it, and he’s just kind of goofing around a little bit. Like, what about this line? It’s not laugh-out-loud funny. It’s just playful:
I became calm enough to release my grasp and partake of pudding. Mr. Pumblechook partook of pudding. All partook of pudding.
Just goofy stuff like that. I don’t know. It’s good.
Benny: Well, I was honestly laughing out loud at, I think, the beginning of chapter two, when he’s describing how he was raised by hand by the sister, and alternating back and forth between that meaning she hit him and that she actually just raised him as her own. And I think it’s even funnier, because I think there are quotes in the Bible — which I didn’t realize until very recently — about raising someone up by the hand, and that being this gesture to raise lame beggars up from poverty and whatnot. So it’s got even more undertones than I initially thought.
Cam: So it’s maybe more like micro humor. I’d just had that thought because I think I said, Rich, that your blog has micro humor. And then I thought, potentially that’s a backhanded compliment.
Rich: Yeah. I’ve got macro humor, bitch.
Cam: Yeah. You’ve got a lot of good micro humor. You know, it makes you kinda smile.
Rich: Yeah. I mean, it’s a tough bar to clear. I’m not laughing out loud very often when I’m reading anything. I’m mostly just smiling slightly. If you saw me reading, maybe my face wouldn’t even change. But in my brain, I’m getting a tiny little dopamine hit, appreciating someone’s wit. Anyway, he’s a witty writer, and he’s an easy-to-read writer.
Benny: Yeah. Much easier than I anticipated, honestly. And it’s just so much fun.
Rich: I also had in my mind that recent meme about literature students not being able to parse the opening of Bleak House. Have you guys seen that?
Cam: Oh, that’s right. It was Bleak House as an example. Yeah.
Rich: Yeah. As part of this ongoing moral panic about post-literate society or something like that. They couldn’t figure out what the hell was happening in the opening paragraphs of Bleak House. And I remember reading those, and I mean, I wouldn’t have failed as badly as those students did, but I could see why it’s not that straightforward to understand what’s going on.
Cam: Yeah. There was something around dinosaurs, and it was obviously alluding to the past, or metaphorical.
Rich: Yeah. The introduction of a metaphor just absolutely… Not like us smart boys.
Cam: The pharmacist actually mentioned that. He’s like, “Oh, I thought the language was a bit old and flowery.” And maybe that’s just his view, or maybe it’s just that everyone reads modern stuff.
Rich: I did have the thought that maybe we’ve put in the reps now, having read George Eliot and Mary Shelley and other sort of Victorian and Regency-era writers. We’ve got the sense for it. We’ve got the ear for it.
Cam: So this was written in the sixties, I think — the 1860s. And I think it’s probably set in the 1810s, 1820s, but it’s not super clear. But I think it’s historical for the time he was writing. One clue was that his parents had died, and he doesn’t know what they look like, and it was before the time of cameras.
Rich: So it’s set in Mary Shelley’s England kind of time period. That’s how I’ve been thinking about it. Frankenstein’s period.
Benny: Nice.
the marshes
Cam: Anyway, Benny, do you wanna just quickly lead us through the opening section in the marshes?
Benny: Yeah. I mean, I’m not entirely sure how much detail to give, and now I’m all self-conscious about giving too much detail. So you’ll just have to stop me, I guess, if I start rampaging on for too long.
Rich: You just wasted ten seconds on that prelude.
Cam: Too much detail on the prelude.
Benny: I know. So, Pip is living with his sister, who I think we just call Mrs. Joe, because her husband is Joe. And I don’t actually know if we know her original name.
Cam: I don’t think we’ve got her name.
Benny: No. And Joe is sort of a simpleton. He’s a blacksmith, not too bright, but very kind towards Pip. And that’s very good, because the sister is a bit of a hell-raiser and has a tendency to get very angry and very upset and smack both Joe and Pip around. Pip, we should say, is maybe — what do you guys think — like, 11, 12 sort of age?
Rich: Yeah, I reckon.
Cam: Or even under that.
Benny: Maybe even under that. One day, he’s walking along the marshes and gets accosted by an escaped convict. The convict says, “You better bring me some bread and a file from your house. Bring me some food.” And Pip is really scared, runs home, grabs a Christmas loaf that’s supposed to be served later that day or the next day or something, and gives it to the convict.
And then, flash forward, they’re all sitting around for Christmas dinner, and right before Mrs. Joe is about to go grab the loaf that he stole, constables show up at the house. They say they’re looking for some escaped convicts on the marshes who might be fighting with one another, and they wanna enlist Joe’s help to make some handcuffs, I believe.
Cam: Is that why they all go? Because the cops go search for the escaped convict, and they all go with them. And Pip’s really worried. I forget why they’re going with them.
Rich: Just for fun, man.
Benny: Honestly, I think they kinda just get invited. Like, “We’re gonna go chase down some convicts over the marshes.”
Rich: That’s what you do for entertainment back in those days. It’s like a police ride-along with a little boy, except he’s just carrying him in a piggyback across the stinky swamp.
Benny: Yeah. And I think Pumblechook wants to go until he realizes that they might have to walk a long time, and he says, “Actually, no. I’ll wait here for you industrious gentlemen to get back.” Because I think we’re supposed to think of Pumblechook as this fat, middle-aged, somewhat lazy guy.
Anyway, they find the convicts, who were fighting. The convict that Pip had met earlier does still have the food on him, I guess, and the file that he gave him. And Joe recognizes that, but the convict, in an early display of loyalty — which is interesting, and I’m assuming this is gonna be a theme throughout — doesn’t say that it was actually Pip who gave him the food. He says he stole it himself. And so Pip is very thankful for that. He just keeps his mouth shut, and the convict gets carted off.
And I think that’s not gonna be the end of the convict. I’m assuming the convict’s gonna make an appearance later. And we do get some foreshadowing fairly soon after that. At one point, Pip and Joe are at the pub, I think, and there’s someone who’s using a file to stir his drink, and only Pip can see the file. I actually didn’t quite understand this part. I don’t think we’re supposed to think that that was the convict, but I think we’re supposed to think that that person knows about Pip’s relationship to the convict.
Cam: And was probably given the file by the convict. It seemed like he was almost trying to let Pip and only Pip see it.
Rich: And then he gives him a substantial sum of money as well.
Cam: Yeah. How much is £2? I forget. Gives him some money.
Rich: Oh, it’s a good amount.
Benny: Yeah. Must have been a lot.
Cam: And the other thing is Pip’s keeping this a secret as well. He decides not to tell anyone.
Rich: Not even Joe. He has a lovely relationship with Joe. They usually talk about everything.
Benny: That’s it.
Cam: And it kinda haunts him. I mean, I wondered about the whole ethical conundrum of this criminal asking you to steal for them, and then you do it, and you keep it quiet. And it’s a sort of setup, I think, that this guy is probably starving. I think Joe even says at one point — because the convict says, “I stole the bread and the file” — and then Joe’s like, “Well, no worries. I don’t want you starving just because you…”
Rich: Also, the convict threatens Pip in very graphic fashion, that he’s got a confederate who’s watching him and who’s gonna cut out his kidneys or something if he doesn’t go and do it and return ASAP. So I think there’s a lot of justification for Pip having done it. He didn’t do anything wrong.
Cam: So is he mainly worried because he feels guilty about it, or because he’s just concerned that this convict has something over him, and it might all come out? I’m just wondering about his anxiety now. I think it’s probably more of the latter.
Rich: Yeah. I think he doesn’t wanna get the bash from Mrs. Joe for stealing the Christmas pie and helping the convict escape. Or maybe that he could even be in some kind of legal trouble or something like that.
Benny: Yeah. One additional element that maybe is important to mention here is that a little bit later on, Joe and Pip and one of Joe’s other workers — what’s his name? Orlick, I think. Orlick.
Cam: Orlick. Pretty dislikable guy.
Benny: Yeah. So Pip asks for the afternoon off, I believe, and Orlick gets it as well. Anyway, they’re all at the pub, and then they come home later at night, and they find Mrs. Joe down on the ground, unconscious, having had her head bashed in from behind, presumably. Nothing appeared stolen from the house, but Mrs. Joe was sick after this for a couple of weeks. And it seems to actually change her personality, perhaps permanently. She seems a little bit nicer even after she recovers.
But I think they either find or they suspect that it was a leg iron that was used to hit her. And Pip recalls that his convict had been wearing a leg iron. And so he’s doubly anxious upon learning this fact, wondering if it was, of course, his convict who committed this crime.
Cam: That reminds me — one thing about this book is it’s extremely episodic. I think he wrote it serially, and it was released every week. And I just had the thought that it’s maybe kinda like a TV show. Because something happens — you know, Pip in the marshes with the convicts — and then Pip at home. And then suddenly this event happens to Mrs. Joe, and then nothing much really happens. Next week, the new episode comes out and something else happens. It goes to Havisham’s, which I think is fine. But yeah, it’s quite distinctive.
Rich: Do you mean that you think we won’t find out who did it or why they did it?
Cam: No. I think it’ll be connected, but it just felt maybe less continuous or connected. If you imagine a TV show, you have to have an event happen, and it’s not necessarily that related to last week. Which, I don’t know what to think of.
Rich: Who do you guys think did that, and why? Because the two main candidates are Orlick, who had a huge fight with her — clearly, they dislike one another — and the convict, because it was his filed-off leg chains or whatever that was at the scene of the crime. But I’m not sure of the motivation for the convict. Was he trying to do Pip a favor by getting rid of his overbearing sister? That was kind of a crazy thing to do.
Cam: Well, even Orlick — is Orlick just nasty? I know they had an argument, but I think Pip even said that everyone’s having arguments with Mrs. Joe. She’s always busting everybody’s balls.
Benny: Yeah. And Orlick had a solid alibi, no? I think Pip mentions that people saw him in town all night.
Rich: Oh, yeah. Because if the convict did it, why? Is it meant to be another favor?
Benny: Yeah, it is weird. Also, with the convict, aren’t we meant to assume that he has been arrested and is presumably behind bars somewhere? Or do we think he’s at large?
Rich: Oh, yeah. They got him. But we know he has confederates.
Benny: That’s true. He has confederates.
Ms Havisham getting revenge on men
Cam: Well, and also, the other slightly weird thing is going on to the next scene, which is where we meet Miss Havisham. She’s a very memorable character. But it’s a little bit random why he goes there. I think she just wants a kid to play.
Benny: It’s arranged by Pumblechook, right?
Rich: Yeah. She’s trying to reenact her trauma upon another man, right? She’s trying to get revenge on the people who’ve slighted her in the past. She’s creating this elaborate play that will play out over years or maybe decades, which is interesting.
Cam: Yeah. I hadn’t actually characterized it as a literal reenactment.
Benny: Me neither. I hadn’t thought about it like that.
Rich: Wait. What do you mean?
Cam: There was one reveal of some of her motives in, like, chapter 27 or something, from Herbert Pocket, where we find out she was left at the altar by this man she loved, who sounded like a bit of a sleazebag, and he left her. And she’s just had this drama and hang-up since then.
So when we meet Miss Havisham — a lot of people probably know this — she’s wearing a wedding dress, and she’s described as ghostly or witch-like. At this point, it’s quite gothic: Miss Havisham’s palace, Satis House. And everything’s decaying in the house. At one point, she’d set up a feast on the table, and everything’s decaying, and her dress is decaying. And the clocks are always set at one time and never change. We find out later that that was probably the time that she was left at the altar.
And there are also subtle clues at this point where she seems to be trying to coax Pip to admire or be interested in Estella, who’s this young girl that’s living with Miss Havisham. Not her daughter, but she’s raising her. And she’s also trying to manipulate Estella to be indifferent at least, or mean at worst, to Pip. So she has these hang-ups. She seems to hate men, and she wants to coach — that’s the way I was interpreting it. Maybe that’s a bit on the nose. I don’t know. It’s something like an older woman educating this young woman to hate men as a way of life.
And another thing as well is that we start to see Dickens’ characters being these kind of almost absurd, non-real, larger-than-life characters and descriptions. We had that a little bit with the Gargerys and Uncle Pumblechook, and the convict probably a little bit, with how scary he was. And this is probably from Pip’s, like, eight-year-old lens. So I suppose it puts us in a world that’s maybe not fully real, in the same way as, I don’t know, a Tarantino movie or Breaking Bad — mostly real, and Infinite Jest had it, and stuff like that — but with these slightly surreal characters that are very memorable. That’s probably one of my favorite parts of Dickens, I suppose: the characterization of these creatures, almost.
Rich: Yeah. Miss Havisham in particular is a wonderful creature, because we find out that she was jilted when she was a youngish maiden, and I’m visualizing her as, like, 60 or something. So she’s been wearing that dress for forty years. She’s never left the house.
Benny: Hasn’t been outside.
Rich: The house is all overgrown with ivy and falling apart. It’s an insane position to be in. And to get her exercise, she does laps around the spoiled wedding feast sitting in the gloom. So imagine you’re an 11-year-old boy — you know, the blacksmith’s adopted son — and you get called up by this insane old rich lady to come and play with her and her adoptive daughter. It is totally bizarre. He’d be like, “Are all rich people like this?”
Cam: The other thing that’s happening now is he’s perhaps for the first time experiencing rich people and upper-class people, and he’s beginning to have anxiety around that. But you also have all these absurd elements to it as well. It’s confusing: what is just upper class, and what is this crazy old woman?
Rich: Yeah. And Estella is the main source of his shame and discontent, I think, because Miss Havisham has been grooming and training her to kind of humiliate and mock Pip, to undermine him and make him feel not good enough and really sense the differences between them. She calls him a common laboring boy or — I can’t remember what she calls him — but she’s definitely making fun of his station and making him really aware that he doesn’t belong in this world.
And I had taken this to be explicit, but maybe you guys hadn’t. I thought Miss Havisham is straight up saying, like, “Love her, love her,” and then she’s gonna break your heart — just trying to set it up to break his heart, basically, as some kind of inverted revenge fantasy.
Cam: No, I definitely knew it was this kind of revenge against men, that she’s using Estella as a vessel. I just hadn’t thought of it as an exact reenactment of her marriage. When you were describing Herbert’s story, I could imagine a flashback scene where she’s actually quite pretty and nice and loving, waiting to get married.
I mean, the other thing with Pip’s shame is, yeah, he gets it from Estella. I think Estella notices his boots and his hands, his working hands. And then he’s also embarrassed when Joe comes to visit and gets things wrong. I think he’s mainly talking to Pip instead of to Havisham, and it’s probably also what he’s wearing.
Benny: Yeah, that was a bizarre scene. He won’t talk to Havisham directly. He’ll only talk via Pip. It was very odd. The scene was odd enough that I honestly did have the thought: does Havisham exist, or is this all happening in Pip’s head somehow, and that’s the reason Joe is just responding to Pip? But, yeah, who knows?
Rich: Pip did nothing wrong, cutting off his uncultured brute of a stepfather.
I guess he’s just so flustered. We haven’t said, but the fact that Pip is going up to the Havisham house for visits is a source of great excitement amongst Joe and Mrs. Joe and all of the hangers-on. It’s this huge deal. They’re all hanging out to get gossip about what goes on up there, and they’re all proud and jealous. And Joe, having to come face to face with it, feels deeply uncomfortable. He’s so aware that that is not the kind of place that he ought to be in. And Pip increasingly feels that way too about Joe, which is really sad.
relating (or not) to the Pip’s class anxiety
Cam: So, Rich, you said you felt it can somewhat relate to modern times — or, I don’t know, personally or not — around the class stuff. I’d be interested to hear you expand on that, if you wanted to.
Rich: Yeah. Well, if you think about who is being made fun of in this book so far, it’s not really the aristocrats, who aren’t really in the picture. It’s more like the aspiring middle classes. So the tradesmen and the professionals and the people who want to enter into this kind of society. And I think that’s still true today: really upper-class people don’t have much status anxiety, because that’s just the water in which they swim. And lower-class, working-class people — I’m less sure about this, but I don’t think they have too much status anxiety. It’s a really distinct middle-class kind of phenomenon.
And also, it’s a source of great anxiety when you do move up in the world, because you don’t know how to behave, and you feel ashamed or embarrassed of your upbringing and maybe your relatives or your friends. I’m thinking of — what’s the vice president’s name?
Cam: JD Vance.
Rich: Vance. Yeah. His Hillbilly Elegy-type shtick about not knowing which cutlery to use when he goes to Yale.
But also, I think I’ve experienced this myself a little bit, of being a bit of an accidental social climber.
Cam: Accidental… I know the feeling.
Rich: Well, I didn’t have a Miss Havisham. I’m a self-made man. But my family was really poor when I was a kid, and it was extremely embarrassing for me. I felt a lot of shame when I was a kid. I hated Christmas. It was my most dreaded time of the year, because all my friends would be like, “What did you guys get for Christmas?” And it’d be a PlayStation or a kayak or whatever. And I’d be like, “Oh, yeah. I got some books and a bar of chocolate or something.” And it was very humiliating to be the poor kid.
Cam: Like that scene in The Pursuit of Happyness with Will Smith’s son, where he looks up at his dad — he’s seven years old — and says, “It’s okay, I don’t need the chocolate bar.”
Rich: Well, we were in a weird situation where it wasn’t hand-to-mouth, not-knowing-where-the-next-meal-is-coming-from poverty. There was always enough food, and the necessities of life were covered, but there were no luxuries. All clothes were hand-me-downs or bought from the Warehouse, and I couldn’t go on school trips if they were expensive, and stuff like that.
And it’s kind of similar to Pip, I think, because he actually lives a pretty good life at the forge. He’s not going hungry, and he has at least one great parent in Joe.
Cam: An autodidact, too. He tries to teach him stuff.
Rich: Yeah. But he just sort of moves up, gets exposed to different circles, and maybe finds them more to his liking. And that’s what’s happened to me. That’s what this book has got me thinking about: I do relate more to the professional-class culture — the values and aesthetics and way of living life — and I relate less to the environment in which I was brought up. I don’t know if I feel much guilt about it, but I do sometimes wonder. I have to think about where I should send my kids to school and stuff like that. And I previously thought I’d just send them to a good old egalitarian public school, and now I’m like…
Cam: Nikole Hannah-Jones.
Rich: Yeah. But now I think… I don’t know. Maybe it would have been cooler if I’d been brought up amongst people who I now consider to be my people, who I have more in common with. And I want to be the kind of guy who loves the poor, and I feel like I can get on with anyone, but to be completely honest, I just have way more in common with white-collar people than with blue-collar people. That’s just the fact of the matter.
Cam: That was good. It’s good to get some of your lore as well.
My thought around it was, I’m not sure how much shame there is now when people are from lowly beginnings, and class anxiety. Being a kid made me different, you know, not having money. And with class as well — Paul Fussell’s book on class shows that it’s not always just money. There’s a lot of behaviors and tastes and beliefs that go into class.
But the class anxiety that I’ve been most exposed to now and seen in others is usually people coming from mid-to-upper-class or upper-class backgrounds, and they’re a little bit embarrassed about it. They might be downwardly mobile people, and they’re sort of ashamed of their privileged upbringing. They view that as kind of bad. I had a friend in late high school who had all sorts of anxieties around his class upbringing. If he’d take friends or a girlfriend to his parents’, instead of Pip looking at Joe and all Joe’s behavior, he’d get embarrassed about his parents coming across as snobby, or even just refined. So he had all this class shame there. And I wondered if that’s the more common version now.
Benny: Interesting.
Cam: Because even in your JD Vance instance, I imagine that going to university is probably the first time for some people to start mixing it with people that aren’t from their background. And now everyone goes to university, and, as we just said, no one can read. So it’s less like suddenly mixing it with John Nash and stuff.
I feel like sometimes people are kinda proud of their backgrounds, and I’ve noticed that in myself a little bit. I probably have kind of a similar background to you, Rich. I kinda like the well-educated, mid-to-upper-class people now. They’re my people. Even though I can’t talk as eloquently sometimes.
Rich: Still haven’t learned which spoon to use at the dinner party.
Cam: Yeah. I do say “archetype” correctly now, I think, though.
Rich: Well, we’re trying to enculture you. We’re doing our best with our charity case.
Cam: Do you know what’s funny with pronunciations? Have you ever seen that sort of comment of someone saying, “Well, actually, if you mispronounce something, it just shows you’ve read it”? So it’s kinda like, “Well, I’m actually smarter because I can’t pronounce things.”
Benny: “I’m not just getting my vocab from movies and shows. I’m reading things and therefore mispronouncing things.” That’s funny.
Rich: But you know, that is a signal, I reckon. It’s a signal of someone who hasn’t found their correct social circle yet, right? Because otherwise, they would have heard the word come up in conversation, and instead they have to socialize with authors on the page.
Cam: Exactly.
Rich: Also, by the way, I heard Benny mispronounce a word for the first time ever recently, and it gave me great pleasure.
Benny: What was it?
Rich: It was “indictment,” and you said “indict-ment.”
Cam: Did he? That’s some Joe Gargery shit right there.
Benny: Yeah. I actually do.
Rich: Cam, I don’t know if Benny should be allowed to come to our social club anymore after that clanger. What do you reckon?
Cam: That’s shocking. We’ll think about it. There might be some more tests.
Benny: That’s so funny.
Rich: But on your point, Cam, it’s interesting. I hadn’t thought of the inversion of it. I find it a bit hard to believe, because, okay, imagine that your dad — well, I don’t know your dad, so maybe I’ll say my dad — is coming to try and mingle at some event, and he doesn’t know what to wear. He doesn’t know how to talk to other people. And it’s not embarrassing, but it’s just a bit off. And then imagine all of your friends and family are like that, and you’re trying to enter this other circle. It’s probably easier for people to code-switch the other way.
Cam: I think it is easier, but people do have anxiety and shame around it. But yeah, you’re right, it would still exist in the more straightforward Pip and Joe case. Sometimes it’s hard to split how much of this is class stuff, how much is just being different and incompatible, and how much is money. Also, how much is it intelligence, which cuts across this class stuff? If you’re hanging out with a bunch of smart people as your new crew, you might be embarrassed about people being ignorant, not necessarily their class.
Benny: So, Rich, just to maybe flesh out your thesis in the context of the book specifically. I suppose you’d view Joe and Mrs. Gargery as lower class, who don’t have any status anxiety, because that certainly seems to be how they’re written. Putting Pip aside, it seems as though Joe is very comfortable with his station in life and doesn’t seem embarrassed about the fact that he can’t read or write.
Cam: Yeah. Well, when Joe goes to meet Pip, he realizes Pip’s becoming a gentleman, and they’re different. And he kinda realizes, okay, that’s for you and not for me. But he doesn’t have hang-ups around it.
Benny: No. Exactly.
Rich: He knows what he is. And I think maybe now would be a good time to bring into the chat what it is that Dickens is trying to say here about how you ought to be in the world, and what it means to be a gentleman, and so on. Because clearly these characters are not all being presented neutrally. We’re clearly meant to be casting judgment on them, and in particular on Pip, as he takes on the exterior trappings of being a gentleman and enters into society.
So I’ll just quickly speedrun the last bit of the plot, which is that he finds out that he has a wealthy benefactor who is gonna raise him up in society, install him in London, give him lots of money, introduce him to the right people, and so on. And the condition of the deal is that it’s anonymous, but obviously we all know or suspect that it’s Miss Havisham who’s doing it, because she’s the very wealthy person who has been grooming him thus far.
He gets up to London, buys beautiful, elaborate clothing, and learns table manners and so on. And as he does so, he becomes more and more ashamed of his background and tries to distance himself from it, culminating in this scene where Joe is really excited to come visit him in London. And it’s just a really ugly, uncomfortable meeting where Joe is wearing clothes that he feels totally awkward in, and the conversation’s stilted. And Pip actually wishes that he could make Joe go away. He says something like he would pay money to not have him there.
And then similarly, Pip returns home to visit his village and decides not to stay with Joe and his sister, but to take a room at the hotel, and ultimately doesn’t even see Joe. He convinces himself that it would be an imposition and that he’s making things more comfortable for all of them, and so on. So you have this interesting divergence, where Pip is becoming more of a gentleman in appearance, but maybe less of a good person internally.
And the money quote I want to get to is this saying of Matthew Pocket, who is one of the sort of upper-middle-class people Pip is staying with in London while he’s getting inducted into society. And this is coming from his son, Herbert, who becomes Pip’s best friend:
It is a principle of his that no man who was not a true gentleman at heart, ever was, since the world began, a true gentleman in manner. He says, no varnish can hide the grain of the wood; and that the more varnish you put on, the more the grain will express itself.
So I think you can kinda map a lot of the characters onto whether they are a gentleman at heart or a gentleman by appearances and manner. Joe, for me, is a gentleman at heart, because he’s just an absolutely wonderful, lovely character, but he in no way resembles or acts like a gentleman, by his rough exterior. And then someone like Estella or Miss Havisham is all exterior and no heart at all. Estella even warns Pip that she has no heart, I think. She literally says, “I have no heart.” And she’s a cruel, capricious kind of person.
Cam: And I was gonna say, the other comparison that’s set up is with Estella and Biddy, who’s Pip’s childhood friend from the forge, who seemingly has great heart and is quite insightful. When he says he wants to become a gentleman to win Estella over, she points out this logical argument: well, either you’re doing it to spite her, and then don’t worry about her, or you’re doing it because you love her, but she sounds like she’s not worth loving. So it’s set up that Biddy has the heart and Estella doesn’t, and Estella is mean to him, but beautiful and upper class.
Rich: And that’s the other characteristic of these characters like Joe and Biddy: they’re sort of presented as if they’re simple buffoons or something, but they’re actually very wise. What Biddy says to Pip is a very apt observation. And Joe often comes out with little wise observations and suggestions as well, even though he has a funny way of expressing himself. And sometimes he kind of surprises himself at having said something smart. He takes a puff on his pipe instead of repeating himself, like he’s letting the impact of having actually said something smart sink in.
And then there are lots of other characters who are variously exemplars of being class-obsessed or status-obsessed at the cost of their personal character.
Benny: No, that’s great. Honestly, I think you’re slightly further ahead in the book than I am. I guess page counts differ.
Cam: Do you know what chapter you’re up to?
Benny: Yeah. I guess a clue would have been that I’m not at chapter 30 yet. For me, page 200 is around chapter 26 or something like that. So he’s got to London. He’s been shown around by Mr. Jaggers and has met Matthew Pocket and realized that Herbert Pocket is the fella that he fought back when he was at Miss Havisham’s — which we haven’t discussed, but it’s a funny little gem.
herbert pocket is a good ‘un
Rich: Well, should we talk about Herbert for a minute? Because he’s a cool character.
Cam: He’s really likable, right? He’s this upper-class guy who is really nice, and he actually reminds me of a guy I know.
Benny: Reminds me of me.
Cam: Yeah. Good luck.
Rich: I think we’re meant to think he’s a failed candidate to be Miss Havisham’s stooge. He was another boy being groomed to be set up for Estella. And actually, that’s interesting. She must have seen something in him that wasn’t fit for the part, whereas she thought Pip was a better fit for the part, which I don’t think reflects well on Pip.
Benny: Yeah. And I think there’s even some slight awkwardness in their first conversation — meaning a conversation between Herbert and Pip — as they’re sort of realizing who’s probably the benefactor. They never say it explicitly, but I think there’s this understanding between them that, “Oh, okay. Maybe we were both there to play a similar part for her. She liked one of us more, and now she’s trying to lead me into my great expectations and make me a gentleman.”
And it’s not like Herbert is poorly off, because his dad is already middle class, and he’s already living this solidly middle-class life in London. But it’s understood, I think, that he’s not gonna be as well off as Pip is bound to be, or as educated or as refined.
Cam: Is Herbert kind of middle class, not already a gentleman?
Benny: Probably Rich can say better than I can, to be honest. That was my initial read of it, but maybe I’m wrong.
Cam: Rich knows all the gradations of different class anxieties.
Rich: I’ve probably been throwing around the terms all wrong, but I think they are of the sort of mercantile class, because he wants to be an insurance clerk or something, and his father, Matthew Pocket, is a respected businessman type.
But okay, basically, here’s how it goes. To be truly upper class, you have to not work, which is something quite different to our time, I think. You have to own land and property so substantial that you don’t work, and it’s considered common and crass to actually apply yourself to anything.
Cam: Like Downton Abbey, right?
Benny: Because r is greater than g, baby.
Rich: Yeah. And this is the position that Pip’s being put into. Notice that Pip’s not receiving any vocational training at all. He’s just receiving a “how to be a toff 101” kind of course. And then below that, you have people like professionals and merchants — like Jaggers, the lawyer — who are highly regarded but are not proper toffs.
Cam: Jaggers, another good character. But yeah, a bit like Fred Vincy in Middlemarch, right, who came from the mercantile class and was an aspiring gentleman.
Rich: Yeah. But Matthew Pocket’s an interesting case, because he’s clearly an exemplar of how to be a true gentleman at heart, but his wife is absolutely status-obsessed and keeps reading peerage handbooks about how her grandfather was unfairly excluded from the peerage or something like that. And she’s neglecting all of her actual children. I don’t know, Benny, if you’ve read that scene yet or not.
Benny: I haven’t, but go on. That’s fine.
Rich: Oh, okay. Well, keep an eye out for her, because she’s another example of a totally vain, self-obsessed, status-hungry person who’s not seeing the human connections right in front of her own face.
Cam: One thing I’ll just put on the table — I think we’ll talk more about class and status next time as well — but it does seem like everyone who is at this sort of upper-class gentleman level is not likable, and they’re all kind of status-obsessed, and they’re not gentlemen inside. Which I wouldn’t be that surprised by, because I feel like part of the message here is that salt-of-the-earth working-class people are really good. And that’s quite a common sentiment now, in how we kinda wanna think about ourselves and how we think of people.
Sometimes I wonder if that’s your view of everyone who’s upper class. A lot of that’s maybe just coming from your own resentment and class anxiety as well, because a lot of these bourgeois values are good. I mean, maybe not quite talking about upper class at the Downton Abbey level. But maybe what you’re capturing is that you have these status games and hierarchies at play here, and maybe one of the messages is that you should not be a gentleman.
Rich: I don’t know about that. I think it’s not as clean-cut as that. Matthew Pocket and Herbert Pocket are the major examples in my mind of how to be a true gentleman, both in station and at heart. It can be done.
Benny: Would you say they’re striving, or do you think they’re quite happy with their current station? Because Matthew Pocket works, right?
Rich: He works.
Cam: Yeah. But let’s just assume Herbert Pocket is kinda thereabouts. Because he reminded me of — as Rich was saying — sometimes you come from these humble beginnings, and then you start rubbing shoulders with well-educated people, and you start noticing different classes. But you start to quite like these people. Herbert Pocket reminds me of someone you meet, and you’re just like, “This guy’s a great person. He’s interesting. He’s smart.”
And it can be easy to have resentment towards people that come from a lot of privilege and a lot of wealth and a lot of class. And I still have that. Don’t get me started on some of the luxury beliefs of upper-class people that annoy me.
Rich: Are you trying to introduce the… Okay: “You hate the rich. Do you have the courage to hate the poor?” Are rich people better people, all else equal?
Cam: Yeah. That’s the old Lindyman tweet, I think.
Rich: I don’t know. We should talk about that maybe next time. I’m not ready to defend that, but it’s an interesting question.
Cam: Yeah. Next time. There’s maybe a middle ground. I love everybody.
small predictions
Rich: Well, people self-select. Anyway, it’s too big a discussion for right now. We gotta go. What can we do real quick? Does anyone wanna take a punt on where things are going in the back half, on the mysteries? I assume Miss Havisham is gonna rug him at some point. What is she gonna do? Try and set him up with Estella and then… Or take his fortune away from him or something? Where are we going with this?
Cam: Or Estella might rug him in a romantic sense as well.
Benny: My perhaps somewhat vanilla-flavored guess is basically what you said. There’s gotta be some sort of financial fall. And I mean, basically, you’ve already described this happening: he starts rising through the world but develops a worse character as a result. He’ll presumably rise to something like the top of that world, then have his fortune taken away, and then realize because of that that true happiness lay in accepting who you are, that sort of thing. It’s gonna be delightfully written regardless, but I could see the message being that simple. I could also see there being many, many more twists and turns.
And I’m very excited to see where the escaped convict makes a reentry, because surely that will happen. And another point on all the status stuff: the escaped convict is the lowest-status person possible in this world. And yet we can’t help but sort of like him, especially given that he’s displayed a lot of loyalty to Pip in that moment. Open question about whether he then proceeded to bash Pip’s sister’s head in and knock her unconscious, but…
Rich: “He made my sister into a vegetable, but he didn’t dob me in.”
Benny: Exactly.
Cam: “He started off threatening to kill me, and then bashed my sister, but right in the middle, we had a moment of niceness.”
Rich: Abolish the prisons.
Oh, how cool are those hulk prison ships, by the way? I had to read about them on Wiki because I was so fascinated. They used to just store prisoners in giant stationary ships on the Thames.
Benny: That’s insane.
Cam: I didn’t go reading about them.
Rich: Go read it. It’s pretty interesting. It’s quite brutal as well, actually. There’s probably a bit of a condemnation inherent in here of the treatment of those people. A lot of them died.
Cam: Are these the ones that get sent over to Australia?
Rich: No. These are just ships that are immobilized and used as gigantic floating prisons.
Benny: Dang. That is interesting. It’s either whaling or sitting in a boat with your fellow convicts in this world, if you’re on a ship.
Rich: Also, I noticed that this is narrated by Pip in the future, and I feel like he’s judging his former self, or at least remonstrating with his former self a little bit. So I think that hints at him having some kind of come-to-Jesus moment in the back half of the book. I’ll be disappointed if he ends up literally swinging a hammer at the blacksmith’s anvil again, because he’s clearly not suited for that kind of life and that kind of work.
Cam: There we go. “It’s not much, but it’s honest work.”
Rich: Yeah. That would be a disappointing ending, but hopefully he threads the needle. I’m sure he will.
Benny: Nice. Are we finishing the book for next time?
Cam: I think that probably makes sense. So if you’re reading along, let’s go to the end for next time. Thanks, listeners, and don’t forget to write in to douevenlit@gmail.com. We love hearing from you, if you have any Dickens takes, or recommendations, or just general queries.
Benny: Sweet. See you next time.